They both involve customers saying nice things about you. But they serve very different purposes.

"We already have Google Reviews. Why do we need testimonials on our website too?"

This is one of the most common questions from small business owners. The answer: Google Reviews and website testimonials do different jobs. You need both.

Google Reviews: What They Do

Google Reviews live on your Google Business Profile. They affect your search ranking, especially for local searches ("dentist near me," "best coffee shop in Brooklyn").

Strengths: - Improve local SEO rankings - Show up in Google Maps and search results - High trust because they're on a third-party platform (can't be faked easily) - Star rating visible before someone even clicks your website

Limitations: - You don't control the display. Google chooses the layout, order, and which reviews are visible. - Negative reviews sit alongside positive ones — you can't curate. - Visitors have to leave your website to read them on Google. - You can't embed Google Reviews on your site without a third-party tool. - You can't ask customers specific questions — they write whatever they want.

Website Testimonials: What They Do

Website testimonials live on your own site. You collect them, curate them, and display them exactly where they'll have the most impact.

Strengths: - You control what's displayed and where - Curated — only your best reviews go public - Placed strategically (homepage, pricing page, next to CTAs) - Custom collection form lets you guide what clients write about - Matches your brand design - Works for any business, not just local ones

Limitations: - No direct SEO benefit (Google doesn't index widget content the same way) - Perceived as less trustworthy than third-party platforms (you could theoretically fake them) - You have to actively collect them

How They Work Together

The smartest approach is using both:

Google Reviews → SEO and discovery. They help people find you. They show a star rating in search results. They build trust before someone even visits your website.

Website testimonials → conversion. Once someone is on your site, curated testimonials placed strategically push them toward action. They address specific concerns, highlight specific services, and are designed to convert.

Think of it as a funnel:

  1. Person searches "web designer Amsterdam"
  2. Sees your Google rating: 4.8 stars (trust established)
  3. Clicks through to your website
  4. Sees curated testimonials on the homepage (trust reinforced)
  5. Visits pricing page — sees value-focused testimonials (hesitation reduced)
  6. Clicks "Contact Us" — sees one more testimonial next to the button (final nudge)

Without Google Reviews, they might not find you. Without website testimonials, they might not convert.

Different Content for Different Purposes

Google Reviews tend to be spontaneous and general: "Great service, highly recommend!" That's fine for SEO and star ratings.

Website testimonials can be guided with specific questions: "What problem were you solving? What results did you see?" This produces detailed, conversion-focused content that addresses real buyer concerns.

You can even ask your best Google reviewers to also leave a testimonial on your collection form with more detail. They've already shown they're willing to write about you.

For Non-Local Businesses

If you're a SaaS, online course creator, freelancer, or any business without a physical location — Google Reviews are less relevant. Your clients are everywhere, not searching "near me."

Website testimonials become your primary social proof. They're even more important for online-only businesses because there's no physical storefront to build trust.

The Practical Takeaway

If you're a local business: focus on Google Reviews for SEO, and add website testimonials for conversion. Both are free to collect.

If you're an online business: website testimonials are your #1 priority. Google Reviews are a nice bonus but not critical.

Either way, start collecting. Every satisfied customer who leaves without giving you a review is a missed opportunity.

Start collecting website testimonials →

Ready to try Quoted?

All features free during early access. No credit card, no limits.

Start Collecting — It's Free