Etsy reviews stay on Etsy. Here's how to bring that social proof to your own website.

If you sell on Etsy, you probably have great reviews there. Customers love your products, leave glowing feedback, and rate you 5 stars.

The problem: those reviews only help you on Etsy. When someone visits your own website (if you have one), your Instagram page, or finds you through Google - those Etsy reviews are invisible.

Bringing your social proof off-platform and onto your own channels is one of the best growth moves a handmade business can make.

Why Your Own Website Needs Testimonials

Etsy takes a cut. Every sale on Etsy costs you fees. Sales through your own website don't. Testimonials on your site help convert visitors who find you outside Etsy.

You don't own your Etsy shop. Etsy can change policies, raise fees, or suspend accounts. Your website and its testimonials are yours forever.

Different audiences. Not everyone shops on Etsy. People who find you on Instagram, Pinterest, or Google need to see social proof on your own site to feel confident buying.

Brand building. Testimonials on your own site build your brand. Testimonials on Etsy build Etsy's marketplace. Invest in your own platform.

How to Collect Testimonials Off-Etsy

You can't just copy Etsy reviews to your website - Etsy's terms prohibit reproducing their content. But you can ask the same customers to leave a review on your site.

Strategy 1: Package insert. Include a small card in every order: "Love your purchase? Leave a review on our website: [link or QR code]. It helps us grow outside of Etsy!"

Strategy 2: Follow-up message. After the Etsy order is marked as delivered, send a message through Etsy: "So glad you love your [item]! If you have 30 seconds, we'd love a review on our website too: [link]"

Strategy 3: Email list. If you've built an email list (through newsletters, freebies, or your website), send a periodic testimonial request to your happiest customers.

Strategy 4: Social media. When customers share your product on Instagram and tag you - DM them: "This made my day! Would you mind leaving a quick review on our website? [link]"

What Handmade Business Testimonials Should Say

Product quality is expected. What sells handmade products is the human story:

Craftsmanship. "You can tell this was made with care. The stitching is perfect and the leather quality is incredible."

Uniqueness. "I've never seen anything like this. It's truly one of a kind."

Gifting. "I bought this as a wedding gift and the bride absolutely loved it. The personalization was beautiful."

Packaging. "The packaging was almost as beautiful as the product itself. Felt like opening a real gift."

Communication. "The seller was so responsive and even sent me a photo of the piece before shipping."

Where to Display Testimonials

Your own website. If you have a Squarespace, Shopify, Wix, or Carrd site - embed a testimonial widget on the homepage and product pages.

Instagram highlights. Create a "Reviews" highlight with screenshots of customer messages, DMs, and your Wall of Love link.

Pinterest. Create pins with testimonial quotes overlaid on product photos. Link back to your website.

Craft fair booth. If you sell at markets, print a few testimonials on a small display next to your products. Physical social proof in a physical space.

Email newsletters. Include a customer review in every email you send. It reminds subscribers why they signed up and nudges them toward a purchase.

Building a Testimonial Habit for Makers

The makers with the strongest off-platform presence are the ones who ask consistently:

After every 5-star Etsy review → send a message asking for a website review too. In every package → include a review card with QR code. On social media → when tagged by a happy customer, ask for a formal testimonial. Monthly → send one email to your list with a review request.

After 6 months of this, you'll have 20-30 testimonials on your own website. That's a Wall of Love that works for you even if Etsy changes its algorithm tomorrow.

Start building your own testimonial library →

Ready to try Quoted?

All features free during early access. No credit card, no limits.

Start Collecting - It's Free